The Victims
Edit
01. Thomas Leroy Marston - shot three times with a .32 Smith & Wesson revolver. (Death Wish)
02. Unnamed Central Park Mugger - shot four times (at least one in the stomach and two in the head) with a .32 Smith & Wesson revolver. (Death Wish)
03-04. Two Unnamed West Side Highway Car Thiefs - shot with a .32 Smith & Wesson revolver. (Death Wish)
05. George Lambert - shot with a .32 Smith & Wesson revolver and fell from the stairs. (Death Wish)
06. Unnamed Vandal - shot in the head with a .32 Smith & Wesson revolver. (Death Wish)
07. Unnamed Vandal - shot in the back with a .32 Smith & Wesson revolver. (Death Wish)
08. Unnamed Vandal - shot in the face with a .32 Smith & Wesson revolver. (Death Wish)
09. Edward A. Smith - shot twice (second - in the head) with a .32 Smith & Wesson Centennial revolver. (Death Sentence)
10. Leroy Thompson - shot twice (second - in the head) in the head with a .32 Smith & Wesson Centennial revolver. (Death Sentence)
11. James Washington - shot in the face with a .32 Smith & Wesson Centennial revolver. (Death Sentence)
12. Ernesto Delgado - shot with a .32 Smith & Wesson Centennial revolver. (Death Sentence)
13. Julio Delgado - shot with a .32 Smith & Wesson Centennial revolver. (Death Sentence)
14. Joseph Krabb - shot with a .32 Smith & Wesson Centennial revolver. (Death Sentence)
15-16. Krabb's Accomplices - shot with a .32 Smith & Wesson Centennial revolver. (Death Sentence)
17. Unknown Machete Mugger - shot multiple times with a .32 Smith & Wesson Centennial revolver. (Death Sentence)
18. Orson Pyne - shot in the throat with a back-up automatic pistol. (Death Sentence)
Unknown Placing/NotesEdit
- In Death Sentence, talking to himself Paul approximately remembers 25 murders, when Machete Mugger was the latest, which may imply that he killed at least 8 additional people in New York City.
Proxy/AssistedEdit
Indirect DeathsEdit
1. Richard Hicks - shot by Orson Pyne with a .45 Luger pistol. (Death Sentence)
2. John R. Datis - shot by Orson Pyne with a .45 Luger pistol. (Death Sentence)
3. William O. Newton - shot by Orson Pyne with a .45 Luger pistol. (Death Sentence)
4. Richard White - stabbed by Jorge Karrasquilo with a kitchen knife. (Death Sentence)
5. Michael Hayes - stabbed by Jorge Karrasquilo with a kitchen knife. (Death Sentence)
6-7. Two Pizzeria Robbers - shot by Orson Pyne with a .45 Luger pistol. (Death Sentence)
8. Unnamed Bus Mugger - shot by James Suit. (Death Sentence)
9-11. Charles Lidell and two other people - shot in vigilante-inspired self-defense gone wrong. (Death Sentence)
12. Peter A. Whitmore - accidentally shot by Orson Pyne with a .45 Luger pistol. (Death Sentence)
13-14. Unnamed Drug Dealer and his client - shot by Orson Pyne with a .45 Luger pistol. (Death Sentence)
15-17. Three unnamed victims of a next vigilante, shot with .32 pistol. (Death Sentence)
Alleged VictimsEdit
- 8 victims of Orson Pyne - as it was suspected that two vigilantes are actually the same person. (Death Sentence)
AttemptedEdit
- Unnamed Female Vandal - was ready to shoot her among with the rest of the gang, but she escaped. (Death Wish)
Assault With InjuriesEdit
1.Street Mugger - beaten with a sock, full of quarters. (Death Wish)
2-3. Unnamed Rapists - shot in the legs with a .32 Smith & Wesson Centennial revolver. (Death Sentence)
Later SuccessEdit
- Joseph Krabb (took 2 attempts) - first attempted to shoot on the street during a robbery attempt, later shot during breaking-and-entering. (Death Sentence)
StalkedEdit
- Two Train Muggers - considered and stalked, but spared because they were not attacking and geographically it may have caused problems for him with a police investigation. (Death Wish)
Considered/Suggested/EndangeredEdit
- Ira Nemzermann - while there was no real intent to kill him, Paul did used the figure of speech which implied such. (Death Wish)
- Paul Benjamin (himself) - considered suicide if he ever gets caught. (Death Wish)
- Undercover Cop - was in Paul's line of fire. (Death Sentence)
- Unnamed Suspect - was in both Pyne's and Paul's line of fire. (Death Sentence)
InfluencedEdit
- Mrs. Wineberg - wounded in the robbery gone wrong. (Death Sentence)
- Unnamed Mugger - shot in the shoulder by Orson Pyne with a .45 Luger pistol. (Death Sentence)
- Unnamed Mugger - shot in a thigh and clavicle by Orson Pyne with a .45 Luger pistol. (Death Sentence)
